§ 5. Perturbation by a compact linear mapping
1. Strict morphisms and properness
Lemma 1 02TK
Let E and F be topological vector spaces, a continuous linear mapping of E into F and U a neighbourhood of 0 in E. Suppose that induces a homeomorphism of U onto a closed subset of F. Then the image I of is closed and induces a homeomorphism of E onto I.
The set is a neighbourhood of 0 in I; it is closed in F, hence the subgroup I of F is locally closed at 0, and consequently it is closed (TG, III, p. 7, prop. 4).
Since Ker() meets U only at 0, we have Ker() and the mapping is injective. Let V be a closed neighbourhood of 0 in E contained in U. Since is a neighbourhood of 0 in (V), there exists a balanced neighbourhood W of 0 in F such that . The set is balanced, hence connected. It contains 0 and is contained in - V). Since and E- V are disjoint open subsets of E, the set is contained in , whence . Consequently is a neighbourhood of 0 in I. This implies that induces a homeomorphism of E onto I.
Proposition 1 02TL
Let E be a separated locally convex space, F a locally convex space and a continuous linear mapping of E into F. The following conditions are equivalent:
(i) The mapping is a strict morphism, its kernel is of finite dimension and its image is closed in F ;
(ii) There exists a closed neighbourhood V of 0 in E such that the restriction of to V is proper (TG, I, p. 72).
(i) (ii) : Suppose that satisfies condition (i). Since the kernel of is of finite dimension, it has a topological supplement in E (III, p. 55, prop. 1), and there exists a compact neighbourhood C of 0 in Ker(). Identify E with Ker(); the set is then a closed neighbourhood of 0 in E. The restriction of to V is composed of the projection of onto which is proper (TG, I, p. 77, cor. 5) and of the restriction of to . Now is a homeomorphism of onto a closed subspace of F, hence is proper (TG, I, p. 72, prop. 2). The composite of two proper mappings is proper (TG, I, p. 73, prop. 5, a)), hence the restriction of to V is proper.
(ii) (i) : Let V be a closed neighbourhood of 0 in E such that the restriction of to V is proper. The set Ker() is then compact (TG, I, p. 75, th. 1); consequently, the vector space Ker() is locally compact, hence of finite dimension (EVT, I, p. 15, th. 3). Let be a topological supplement of Ker() in E (prop. 1 of III, p. 55); put . The set is closed in V. The mapping is proper (TG, I, p. 74, cor. 1) and injective, hence is a homeomorphism of onto a closed subset of F (TG, I, p. 72, prop. 2). By Lemma 1, the restriction of to is a homeomorphism of onto a closed subspace of F, hence is a strict morphism with closed image.
2. Perturbation of injective or surjective linear mappings
Theorem 1 02TM
Let E and F be separated locally convex spaces and a strict morphism of E into F, whose kernel is of finite dimension and whose image is closed. Let be a compact linear mapping of E into F. The linear mapping is a strict morphism, its kernel is of finite dimension and its image is closed.
According to prop. 1 of III, p. 71, there exists a closed neighbourhood V of 0 in E such that the restriction of to V is proper. Since is compact, there exists a closed neighbourhood W of 0 contained in V such that the set is relatively compact. Put . The restriction of to W is proper (TG, I, p. 74, cor. 1). The mapping from W into is proper because the mapping pr from W into F is proper (TG, I, p. 73, prop. 5, d)). The mapping from into is a homeomorphism, and the mapping pr from into F is proper (TG, I, p. 77, cor. 5). The composed mapping pr from W into F is therefore proper (TG, I, p. 73, prop. 5, a)). But this mapping is none other than the restriction of to W. According to the prop. 1 of III, p. 71 is a strict morphism, its kernel is of finite dimension and its image is closed.
Lemma 2 02TN
Let E and F be Fréchet spaces and . The following conditions are equivalent:
(i) The cokernel of is of finite dimension ;
(ii) The mapping is a strict morphism with closed image whose kernel is of finite dimension.
(i) (ii) : Suppose that the cokernel of is of finite dimension. The mapping is then a strict morphism (lemma 6 of III, p. 52). According to prop. 2 of EVT, IV, p. 27, the image of is closed in endowed with the weak topology, and fortiori in . The kernel of is the orthogonal of the image of loc. cit.) ; it is therefore of finite dimension. Finally, is a strict morphism from into according to theorem 1 of EVT, IV, p. 28.
(ii) (i) : Suppose that is a strict morphism. According to EVT, IV, p. 28, th. 1, the image of is closed. The kernel of is the orthogonal of Im() (EVT, IV, p. 27, prop. 2) ; if this kernel is of finite dimension, the image of is of finite codimension in F.
Theorem 2 02TO
Let E and F be Fréchet spaces, a continuous linear mapping whose cokernel is of finite dimension, and a compact linear mapping. The linear mapping is a strict morphism, its cokernel is of finite dimension and its image is closed.
According to lemma 6 of III, p. 52, it suffices to show that the cokernel of is of finite dimension. Now, according to prop. 9 of III, p. 9, the mapping from into is compact ; theorem 2 results from theorem 1 and lemma 2.
3. Perturbation of Fredholm mappings
Theorem 3 02TP
Let E be a locally convex space, F a separated locally convex space, a Fredholm mapping from E into F and a compact linear mapping from E into F. Then is a Fredholm mapping, and one has ind() ind().
We shall prove the theorem in three steps.
A) Suppose that E and F are Banach spaces. Proposition 2 of III, p. 42 shows that the linear mapping is a strict morphism with closed image whose kernel and cokernel are of finite dimension. Since E and F are Banach spaces, Theorems 1 and 2 of III, p. 73 imply that, for every , the linear mapping has these same properties, and is therefore a Fredholm mapping (III, p. 42, Proposition 2). The mapping of into the set of Fredholm mappings of E into F is continuous. By Theorem 1 of III, p. 58, the mapping ind() is locally constant. Since the interval of is connected, this mapping is constant. Hence ind() ind().
B) Suppose that E = F and . By Proposition 5 of III, p. 5, there exist a Banach space G, a continuous linear mapping and a compact linear mapping such that . The endomorphism of G is compact. By A), is a Fredholm endomorphism of G of index zero. But then is a Fredholm endomorphism of E of index zero (III, p. 49, Proposition 10, f )).
C) General case. Let be a quasi-inverse of . The endomorphisms and of F differ from by compact linear mappings. By B), they are Fredholm endomorphisms of F of index zero. It follows that is a Fredholm endomorphism (III, p. 40, n) of the same index as III, p. 43, n, formula (2)).
Corollary 1 02TQ
Let E and F be separated locally convex spaces and . In order that be a Fredholm mapping, it is necessary and sufficient that there exist a mapping such that the linear mappings and be compact.
Since a continuous linear mapping of finite rank is compact, the stated condition is necessary.
Let be an element of such that the linear mappings and are compact. By Theorem 3 and are Fredholm mappings. Let and be quasi-inverses of and respectively. Put and . With the notations of No. of III, p. 40, one has and , whence . It follows that is a quasi-inverse of .
Corollary 2 02TR
Let E and F be separated locally convex spaces and . The following conditions are equivalent:
(i) The mapping is a Fredholm mapping of index zero;
(ii) There exists an isomorphism of E onto F such that is of finite rank ;
(iii) There exists an isomorphism of E onto F such that is compact.
(i) (ii) : Suppose that is a Fredholm mapping of index zero. There exist decompositions into topological direct sums and with and finite-dimensional such that vanishes on and defines by restriction an isomorphism of onto III, p. 42, prop. 2). If ind() , then the dimensions of and are equal and there exists an isomorphism of E onto F extending . The kernel of contains , hence is of finite rank.
We have (ii) (iii) since every continuous linear mapping of finite rank from E into F is compact, and (iii) (i) according to th. 3.
4. Perturbation of Riesz endomorphisms
Let E be a Banach space. Recall (cf. III, p. 5, prop. 3) that the set of compact endomorphisms of E is a closed two-sided ideal of the Banach algebra . The quotient Banach algebra is called the Calkin algebra of E; it is denoted by alk(E). We denote by the canonical homomorphism of onto alk(E). According to Cor. 1 of III, p. 74, an endomorphism of E is a Fredholm endomorphism if and only if is invertible in the algebra alk(E).
Proposition 2 02TS
Let be such that in the algebra alk(E). Then is a Riesz endomorphism of E.
Let be an integer such that . Let be the polynomial . Let . We thus have and . Since the endomorphisms and of E commute, it suffices to prove that is a Riesz endomorphism of E (III, p. 49, prop. 9).
Since , there exists, by definition of the quotient norm in the space alk(E), a compact endomorphism of E and an endomorphism of E such that and . According to Corollary 1 of I, p. 22, the element is an automorphism of E. Since is compact, is a Fredholm endomorphism of E of index 0 (Cor. 2 of III, p. 74). For every integer , denote by the kernel of . To prove that is a Riesz endomorphism of E, it suffices to prove that there exists an integer such that III, p. 46, def. 2 and III, p. 46, remark).
Reason by contradiction by supposing the sequence strictly increasing. For every , let be the canonical mapping of E onto the normed space . Let be a real number such that . Let . Since is different from , there exists an element such that and such that (indeed, there exists of norm so, for every , there exists such that and ).
Let be two integers such that . We have
since and . Moreover, note that
But since and , we have , whence
The inequality (1) therefore gives the lower bound
The sequence therefore has no value of adherence in E, which contradicts the fact that the image by of the unit ball of E is relatively compact, since is compact (remark 1 of III, p. 2).
Corollary 1 02TT
Let E be a separated locally convex space and let . In order that be a Riesz endomorphism, it is necessary and sufficient that there exist an element of which commutes with and such that is compact.
Since every continuous linear mapping of finite rank is compact, the condition is necessary (III, p. 47, prop. 6 d)). Let us prove that it is sufficient. Let be an element of which commutes with and such that the endomorphism of E is compact. There exist a Banach space G, a continuous linear mapping and a compact linear mapping such that III, p. 5, prop. 5). The endomorphism of G is compact. According to prop. 2, the linear mapping is a Riesz endomorphism of G. But then is a Riesz endomorphism of E (III, p. 49, prop. 10, g)). Since and commute, is a Riesz endomorphism of E (III, p. 49, prop. 9).
Corollary 2 02TU
Let E be a separated locally convex space, a Riesz endomorphism of E and a compact linear mapping. If and commute, then is a Riesz endomorphism of E.
Let be the canonical quasi-inverse of . It commutes with and with III, p. 47, prop. 6), hence with . The endomorphism of E is the sum of the continuous linear mapping of finite rank and the compact linear mapping , hence is compact. It follows that is a Riesz endomorphism of E (corollary 1).
Proposition 3 02TV
Let E be a Banach space. Let be an endomorphism of E, and let A be its commutant in . The closure B of in the algebra alk(E) is a Banach algebra. In order that be a Riesz endomorphism of E, it is necessary and sufficient that be invertible in B.
Since is a unital subalgebra of alk(E), its closure B is a Banach algebra. If is a Riesz endomorphism of E, the element possesses an inverse in (cor. 1), hence in B. Conversely, suppose that has an inverse in B. By definition of B, there exists an element of A such that
whence . According to prop. 2, the linear mapping is a Riesz endomorphism of E. The same is true of since and commute (III, p. 49, prop. 9).
5. The theory of Frédéric Riesz
Let E be a separated locally convex space and let be a compact endomorphism of E. Let . The endomorphism is compact, hence is a Riesz endomorphism of E (cor. 2 of prop. 2 of III, p. 75); denote by and its null space and its conull space. According to prop. 6 of III, p. 47, the following properties hold:
(i) The vector subspaces and of E are closed and stable under ;
(ii) The locally convex space E is the topological direct sum of and ;
(iii) The mapping defines by restriction an automorphism of ;
(iv) The vector space is finite-dimensional, and there exists an integer such that for every .
These properties determine the spaces and uniquely (A, VIII, p. 26, remark 2).
Lemma 3 02TW
Let X be a topological space whose topology possesses a countable basis. Every discrete subset of X is countable.
Let be a countable basis of the topology of X and let D be a discrete subset of X. For each element of D, there exists an element of such that . The mapping from D into defined by is injective, whence the lemma.
Theorem 4 02TX
Let E be a separated locally convex space and let be a compact endomorphism of E. The set Σ of the such that is not an automorphism of E is a countable, closed and discrete subset of the field K.
The set Σ is also the set of such that is not injective and the set of such that is not surjective.
There exist a Banach space G, a continuous linear mapping and a compact linear mapping such that III, p. 5, prop. 5). The endomorphism of G is compact, and for to be an automorphism of E it is necessary and sufficient that be an automorphism of G (prop. 10 of III, p. 49, e)). It is therefore enough for us to prove the theorem when E is a Banach space, which we henceforth suppose.
Let . Since the index of a Riesz endomorphism is zero, it amounts to the same thing to say that the mapping is an automorphism of E, or that it is injective, or again that it is surjective.
The set Σ is closed in K since the set of automorphisms of E is open in . Let be an element of Σ. We have . Denote by N the nilspace of and by I its conilspace, and denote by and the endomorphisms of I and N which defines by passing to the subspaces. Then is an automorphism of I, and there exists a neighbourhood U of in K such that is an automorphism of I for every . The endomorphism of N is nilpotent; for every , we have
therefore is an automorphism of N. Consequently, the set is reduced to the single element and the set Σ is discrete. It is countable by the lemma 3.
6. Fredholm Alternative
Proposition 4 (Fredholm Alternative) 02TY
Let E be a Banach space and let be a compact endomorphism of E. Let be an element of K . Let F be the kernel of and G the kernel of .
a) The spaces F and G have the same finite dimension ;
b) For , there exists such that if and only if for all ;
c) For , there exists such that if and only if for all .
In particular, one and only one of the following conditions is valid:
(i) The space F is nonzero ;
(ii) For every , there exists such that .
Replacing by , we reduce to the case where .
The endomorphism is compact by corollary 1 of III, p. 9. The endomorphisms of E and of are therefore Riesz endomorphisms (cor. 2 of prop. 2 of III, p. 75). In particular, their kernels F and G have finite dimension. Since and the index of is zero, the dimension of F is equal to that of G by formula (3) of III, p. 43.
For an element of E, the equation has a solution if and only if belongs to the image of . Since the dual of the cokernel of identifies with the kernel G of Ker() (EVT, IV, p. 27, prop. 2), this is the case if and only if for all .
For an element of , the equation has a solution if and only if belongs to the image of . Since the image of is the orthogonal of the kernel F of (EVT, IV, p. 27, prop. 2) this is the case if and only if for all .
Example 02TZ
Let X be a compact space, a measure on X, real or complex according as K is equal to or , and a continuous function.
Let E denote the Banach space . Suppose given a function and . Let us study the problem of the existence and uniqueness of the solutions of the integral equation
For this, introduce the set of the solutions of the associated homogeneous equation
and the set of the solutions of the transposed homogeneous equation of (4), that is to say
If it is not empty, the set of the solutions of (3) is an affine subspace of E with direction .
For and , put
the mapping thus defined is a compact endomorphism of the Banach space E (cor. of prop. 2 of III, p. 26). The dual of E consists of the measures on X, real or complex according as K is equal to or (INT, III, p. 47, § 1, n, def. 2). The transpose of is the endomorphism of characterized by the relation for and , that is to say
for and (INT, III, p. 84, § 4, n, th. 2).
Lemma 4 02U0
The linear mapping from into defined by is injective, and its image is the kernel of .
If satisfies , then formula (5) implies , hence the mapping is injective.
Let be a measure belonging to the kernel of . According to relation (6), one has
for every continuous function . The measure is therefore equal to the measure , where is the continuous function from X into K defined by
for every . Formula (8) then implies that the function belongs to .
Conversely, let be a continuous function belonging to and put . For every continuous function , we therefore have
so that . This proves Lemma 4.
By applying Proposition 4 and Theorem 4 of III, p. 78. to the endomorphism , one then obtains the following statements.
Theorem 5 02U1
Let .
a) The sets and are finite-dimensional vector subspaces of and their dimensions are equal ;
b) In order that equation (3) have at least one solution , it is necessary and sufficient that one have for every function . The set of solutions of (3) is then an affine subspace of with direction ;
c) One of the following conditions, which exclude each other, is satisfied :
(i) For every function , there exists a unique
solution of the integral equation (3) ;
(ii) The homogeneous equation (4) possesses a nonzero solution
Corollary 02U2
The set of the for which the space is not zero is a countable, closed and discrete subset of K.
Exercises
In the following exercises, when E is a Banach space, one denotes by alk(E) the Calkin algebra . One denotes by the canonical projection of into alk(E).
If E is a complex Hilbert space, alk(E) is provided with the involution deduced from the involution of by passing to the quotient.
See the exercises for § 5.